Every ruling has a reason.

Only 3% are ever written down.

Every ruling
has a reason.

Only 3% are ever written down.

THE OTHER 97% IS BELOW

HRG. AUDIO02:14:07R-02FINDINGS ON RECORDR-01BENCH RULINGR-03OBJ. OVERRULEDR-04REASONINGR-05MOTION GRANTEDR-06STATED BASISMEM. OPINIONP. 14O-02FINDINGS / CONCL.O-01MEMORANDUM OP.O-03ORDERO-04CONFIRMATIONO-05ON APPEAL
HRG. AUDIO02:14:07R-02FINDINGS ON RECORDR-01BENCH RULINGR-03OBJ. OVERRULEDR-04REASONINGR-05MOTION GRANTEDR-06STATED BASISMEM. OPINIONP. 14O-02FINDINGS / CONCL.O-01MEMORANDUM OP.O-03ORDERO-04CONFIRMATIONO-05ON APPEAL
Hearing transcripts & all federal docketsEnter to ask

4 of the top 5 AmLaw 100 firms rely on Bench IQ for a strategic edge in court and at the negotiating table.

IN THE PRESS

THE ADVANTAGE

Understand how your judge makes decisions.

Bench IQ connects filings, hearing transcripts, and orders to reveal what mattered to the judge, helping you build stronger arguments and negotiate better terms.

01 / HEARING TRANSCRIPTS

See what mattered to the judge.

Read the judge’s questions, concerns, and reasoning in their own words.

Bench IQ01 / 04
PAGE 13
The Court

“Wait. If you're going to seek summary judgment, why shouldn't I get the whole, complete picture and then figure out what's relevant later on the issue of the repose? I mean, why are you pigeonholing me, much less the plaintiffs?

Counsel

Because, your Honor, our position is that insurance, title, and registration -- so asking a Ford witness: "What do you think about when the ultimate consumer had registered the title of the vehicle? What do you think about whether he or somebody else took out insurance? What do you think about CARFAX," which Ford has nothing to do about?

Hr’g Tr. 13:15–25, Camacho v. Ford Motor Co., No. 5:19-cv-00023 (W.D. Tex. Apr. 11, 2019).

02 / RELATED FILINGS

Learn what worked and what didn’t.

Explore how lawyers framed their arguments, the evidence they presented, and how the judge ultimately responded.

Bench IQ02 / 04
What are the factors that the judge has stated which influenced his decision?

Plaintiff’s likelihood-of-confusion expert, Ostein: motion denied, with strict limits. She could address specific matters she had actually analyzed, including how products were sold and advertised, buyer sophistication, and purchasing care. She could not give the ultimate opinion that confusion was likely or discuss factors absent from her report. Experience alone was insufficient: “She must show how her experience is a sufficiently reliable basis upon which to justify the opinion that she is rendering as to a specific factor. 158:5-7

Supporting Memorandum for Motion in LimineOpen filing
Defendants’ Omnibus Motion in LimineOpen filing

Hr’g Tr. 58:5-7, Solid 21, Inc. v. Richemont N. Am., Inc., No. 1:19-cv-01262 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 30, 2023).

03 / RESEARCH DEPTH

Go deeper than time allows.

Analyze thousands of pages across cases to uncover overlooked arguments and understand why judges reached different conclusions. Weeks of research, distilled into hours.

Bench IQ03 / 04
Find hearings where judges ruled on challenges to experience-based experts like ours. Did any rule differently, and why?

No trademark court went the other way, but two judges applied the same test in similar scenarios to experience-based experts, with different results:

CaseOutcomeWhy
Solid 21 v. Richemont
Subramanian, J. · S.D.N.Y. · 2023
Admitted, limitedExperience must support specific factors, not an ultimate confusion opinion. 159:1-2
Dahua Tech. v. Zhang
Talwani, J. · D. Mass. · 2021
ExcludedExperience didn’t show a reliable method: “What are the reliable principles and methods...?” 1125:7-8

04 / CITATIONS

Trace each answer to its source.

Follow citations to the exact passages behind the answer. Review the context and put it to work.

Bench IQ04 / 04

The judge expressly contrasted his decision with cases in which the underlying events occurred well before filing. In that situation, he explained, that courts are less likely to permit discovery that postdate the complaint. 119:17-18 Here, the close timing between termination, notice of claims, and filing supported allowing the later discovery.Arun SubramanianSep. 12, 2023In Olohan v. Google LLC et al...I think the courts are less likely to permit discovery that postdate the complaint....Copy citationOpen transcript

He also included searches of individual defendant Tiffany Miller’s personal emails, although that relief was outside the motion itself: “It wasn't part of the motion to compel, but I'm going to wrap it in the same ruling.”

Bench IQ01 / 04
PAGE 13
The Court

“Wait. If you're going to seek summary judgment, why shouldn't I get the whole, complete picture and then figure out what's relevant later on the issue of the repose? I mean, why are you pigeonholing me, much less the plaintiffs?

Counsel

Because, your Honor, our position is that insurance, title, and registration -- so asking a Ford witness: "What do you think about when the ultimate consumer had registered the title of the vehicle? What do you think about whether he or somebody else took out insurance? What do you think about CARFAX," which Ford has nothing to do about?

Hr’g Tr. 13:15–25, Camacho v. Ford Motor Co., No. 5:19-cv-00023 (W.D. Tex. Apr. 11, 2019).

“

“

“

I wouldn’t want to be in a case where the other side has this tool and we don’t.

— ASSOCIATE, AMLAW 10 FIRM

COVERAGE

COVERAGE

Judicial intelligence
across the federal courts.

Bench IQ covers all U.S. federal district and bankruptcy courts, connecting filings, hearing transcripts, and orders to uncover the story behind the ruling.

FEB 27
DKT. 412Motion to approve bidding procedures
MAR 10
DKT. 421Committee objection to sale timeline
MAR 14
DKT. 430Debtors’ reply in support
MAR 18
HEARINGHR’G TR. 36:4

“I’ll set the bid deadline at sixty days.”

MAR 21
DKT. 455Order approving bidding procedures
FEB 27
DKT. 412Motion to approve bidding procedures
MAR 10
DKT. 421Committee objection to sale timeline
MAR 14
DKT. 430Debtors’ reply in support
MAR 18
HEARINGHR’G TR. 36:4

“I’ll set the bid deadline at sixty days.”

MAR 21
DKT. 455Order approving bidding procedures
FEB 27
DKT. 412Motion to approve bidding procedures
MAR 10
DKT. 421Committee objection to sale timeline
MAR 14
DKT. 430Debtors’ reply in support
MAR 18
HEARINGHR’G TR. 36:4

“I’ll set the bid deadline at sixty days.”

MAR 21
DKT. 455Order approving bidding procedures

FILINGS

What was filed

Motions, objections, and agreements that put the issues before the court.

HEARING TRANSCRIPTS

What was said

Lawyers’ arguments and judges’ questions, concerns, and reasoning in their own words.

ORDERS

What was decided

The court’s decisions, connected to the arguments and proceedings behind them.

FILINGS

What was filed

Motions, objections, and agreements that put the issues before the court.

HEARING TRANSCRIPTS

What was said

Lawyers’ arguments and judges’ questions, concerns, and reasoning in their own words.

ORDERS

What was decided

The court’s decisions, connected to the arguments and proceedings behind them.

FILINGS

What was filed

Motions, objections, and agreements that put the issues before the court.

HEARING TRANSCRIPTS

What was said

Lawyers’ arguments and judges’ questions and reasoning in their own words.

ORDERS

What was decided

The court’s decisions, connected to the arguments and proceedings behind them.

WHAT CUSTOMERS SAY

WHAT CUSTOMERS SAY

INTEGRATIONS

Works where you already work.

Bring Bench IQ’s judicial intelligence into your AI assistant. Strengthen your arguments, drafts, and negotiations with cited insights.

  • Harvey
  • Legora
  • ChatGPT
  • Claude
  • Gemini

and any MCP-compatible assistant your firm approves

  • Harvey
  • Legora
  • ChatGPT
  • Claude
  • Gemini

and any MCP-compatible assistant your firm approves

  • Harvey
  • Legora
  • ChatGPT
  • Claude
  • Gemini

and any MCP-compatible assistant your firm approves

Matter 0412-003
@bench-iq How has Judge Okafor ruled on KEIP motions challenged by the U.S. Trustee?
Bench IQ · Searched 312 hearing transcripts · Bankr. D. Del.done

Across 9 contested KEIP hearings since 2022, Judge Okafor approved 6 — but only after metrics were tightened on the record.1

She has twice rejected plans where targets were “already within reach” at filing, signalling she reads them as disguised retention bonuses.2

1In re Halvorsen Retail, Hr’g Tr.42:7–15
2In re Marlow Freight, Hr’g Tr.18:3–22
Research by Bench IQ
Matter 0412-003
@bench-iq How has Judge Okafor ruled on KEIP motions challenged by the U.S. Trustee?
Bench IQ · Searched 312 hearing transcripts · Bankr. D. Del.done

Across 9 contested KEIP hearings since 2022, Judge Okafor approved 6 — but only after metrics were tightened on the record.1

She has twice rejected plans where targets were “already within reach” at filing, signalling she reads them as disguised retention bonuses.2

1In re Halvorsen Retail, Hr’g Tr.42:7–15
2In re Marlow Freight, Hr’g Tr.18:3–22
Research by Bench IQ
Matter 0412-003
@bench-iq How has Judge Okafor ruled on KEIP motions challenged by the U.S. Trustee?
Bench IQ · Searched 312 hearing transcripts · Bankr. D. Del.done

Across 9 contested KEIP hearings since 2022, Judge Okafor approved 6 — but only after metrics were tightened on the record.1

She has twice rejected plans where targets were “already within reach” at filing, signalling she reads them as disguised retention bonuses.2

1In re Halvorsen Retail, Hr’g Tr.42:7–15
2In re Marlow Freight, Hr’g Tr.18:3–22
Research by Bench IQ

USE CASES

USE CASES

Ask your question.
Find your advantage.

Build stronger arguments, prepare for hearings, and negotiate better terms with insights from the court record.

Build stronger arguments, prepare for hearings, and negotiate better terms with insights from the court record.

Write stronger briefs

Bench IQ connects arguments and evidence in prior filings with judges’ reasoning in transcripts and resulting rulings, helping you strengthen your position and address weaknesses before you file.

Bench IQ connects arguments and evidence in prior filings with judges’ reasoning in transcripts and resulting rulings, helping you strengthen your position and address weaknesses before you file.

Bench IQ connects judges’ questions and counsel’s answers in hearing transcripts with the underlying briefs and rulings, helping you anticipate concerns and prepare more persuasive responses.

Bench IQ compares how courts approach similar issues through filings, hearing transcripts, and rulings, helping you choose a venue with greater insight into how your arguments may be received.

Bench IQ connects proposed agreements and objections with hearing discussions and court approvals, revealing which terms drew resistance and how concerns were resolved to help you negotiate stronger agreements.

Bench IQ connects expert reports and testimony with challenges and judicial reasoning, revealing strengths and vulnerabilities to help you select experts, prepare witnesses, and sharpen your examination.

Bench IQ traces similar requests through filings, hearing exchanges, and rulings to explain why they succeeded or fell short, helping you decide what to pursue and when to act.

Bench IQ connects emerging arguments in filings with judges’ reactions and reasoning in hearings, helping you track how the law is developing before published opinions catch up.

Write stronger briefs

Bench IQ connects arguments and evidence in prior filings with judges’ reasoning in transcripts and resulting rulings, helping you strengthen your position and address weaknesses before you file.

Bench IQ connects arguments and evidence in prior filings with judges’ reasoning in transcripts and resulting rulings, helping you strengthen your position and address weaknesses before you file.

Bench IQ connects judges’ questions and counsel’s answers in hearing transcripts with the underlying briefs and rulings, helping you anticipate concerns and prepare more persuasive responses.

Bench IQ compares how courts approach similar issues through filings, hearing transcripts, and rulings, helping you choose a venue with greater insight into how your arguments may be received.

Bench IQ connects proposed agreements and objections with hearing discussions and court approvals, revealing which terms drew resistance and how concerns were resolved to help you negotiate stronger agreements.

Bench IQ connects expert reports and testimony with challenges and judicial reasoning, revealing strengths and vulnerabilities to help you select experts, prepare witnesses, and sharpen your examination.

Bench IQ traces similar requests through filings, hearing exchanges, and rulings to explain why they succeeded or fell short, helping you decide what to pursue and when to act.

Bench IQ connects emerging arguments in filings with judges’ reactions and reasoning in hearings, helping you track how the law is developing before published opinions catch up.

Write stronger briefs

Bench IQ connects arguments and evidence in prior filings with judges’ reasoning in transcripts and resulting rulings, helping you strengthen your position and address weaknesses before you file.

Bench IQ connects arguments and evidence in prior filings with judges’ reasoning in transcripts and resulting rulings, helping you strengthen your position and address weaknesses before you file.

Bench IQ connects judges’ questions and counsel’s answers in hearing transcripts with the underlying briefs and rulings, helping you anticipate concerns and prepare more persuasive responses.

Bench IQ compares how courts approach similar issues through filings, hearing transcripts, and rulings, helping you choose a venue with greater insight into how your arguments may be received.

Bench IQ connects proposed agreements and objections with hearing discussions and court approvals, revealing which terms drew resistance and how concerns were resolved to help you negotiate stronger agreements.

Bench IQ connects expert reports and testimony with challenges and judicial reasoning, revealing strengths and vulnerabilities to help you select experts, prepare witnesses, and sharpen your examination.

Bench IQ traces similar requests through filings, hearing exchanges, and rulings to explain why they succeeded or fell short, helping you decide what to pursue and when to act.

Bench IQ connects emerging arguments in filings with judges’ reactions and reasoning in hearings, helping you track how the law is developing before published opinions catch up.

SECURITY & TRUST

Security for privileged work.

Your queries, documents, and work product deserve care at every step.

SOC 2

TYPE II

01

No training on your data.

Your queries and documents are never used to train AI models.

02

Encrypted in transit and at rest.

Your work product stays confidential end to end.

03

SSO and audit logging.

Use your firm’s identity provider, with a record of who accessed what.

04

Retention controls.

You decide how long we keep your research, and it is deleted on request.

MATTER TRACKING

Recover your research costs.

Tag every research session to a client and matter. Usage is itemized by matter at your actual cost, so research charges can be documented in client bills and fee applications the same way you handle other research expenses.

RESEARCH BY MATTER · OCTOBER 2026

In re Halvorsen Retail

0412-003

38%

In re Calder Freight

0377-011

24%

In re Northvale Health

0419-002

17%

In re Brightwater Mills

0295-018

13%

Non-billable

0000-000

8%

Export itemized cost report

Bring us the question on your desk

See what your judge isn’t putting in writing.
Bring us your question. We’ll go beyond the written opinions.

Bring us the question on your desk

See what your judge isn’t putting in writing.
Bring us your question. We’ll go beyond the written opinions.

Bring us the question
on your desk

See what your judge isn’t putting in writing.
Bring us your question. We’ll go beyond the written opinions.